In life, we often encounter situations that prompt us to reflect on punishment, balancing discipline with children or considering the long-term impact of abuse. Such experiences can deeply influence a person’s physical and mental well-being, paving the way for future challenges. Recently, while reading Chief Justice of India, DY Chandrachud’s recollection of his school caning, I felt inspired to write this blog. As a fellow alum of the same school, the shared memories of being severely beaten and caned in grade 6, brought back my own painful experiences, blending a mix of nostalgia and sombre reflection. In my book “Overflow: Live The Life You Want,” I delve into personal experiences that have shaped my adult life, emphasizing the profound impact of childhood experiences and the necessity of comprehending the effects of abuse on children.
Proportionate Punishment for Children
In parenting and education, a crucial dilemma arises when considering how to discipline a child following a mistake. What constitutes a fair and just punishment? Who holds the authority to determine whats a proportionate punishment? Are there set guidelines to follow? Is there a menu card? These essential queries demand our attention. Can discipline truly exist without nurturing personal growth and comprehension? Finding the delicate equilibrium between correction and empathy is very essential.
In an episode of The West Wing (Season 3, episode 7: “The Indians in the Lobby”), a gripping scenario unfolds where a boy commits a serious crime by killing someone and seeking refuge in Italy. The Italian government’s refusal on extraditing the boy without an assurance from the USA that he won’t face the death penalty raises intricate diplomatic issues.
Josh, portrayed by Bradley Whitford as the Deputy Chief of Staff to the American President, engages in a compelling conversation with the Italian Ambassador Fedrigotti, played by Armando Pucci, in search of a resolution.
During the conversation Fedrigotti asks Josh to imagine a situation where a father justifies extreme physical abuse towards his misbehaving daughter who is running around throwing food and displaying defiance. The father initially tries to intervene by asking her to stop but when this parental authority is met with defiance, the father wields a wine bottle and strikes the girls head, followed by throwing her to the ground, subjecting her to repeated physical blows.
Josh remains unconvinced arguing that the gravity of the situation, involving a murder rather than throwing food, questions the validity of comparing the two scenarios.
By posing the question, “Is there a crime that the girl could commit that would justify the father’s actions?” Fedrigotti prompts a deep reflection on the rationale behind extreme forms of punishment. The weight carried by the term “justified” challenges the notion of whether any offense—no matter how severe—could justify the father’s brutal and disproportionate response in the analogy, akin to the potential death penalty faced by the boy in the real-life scenario.
This comparison serves as a catalyst for a broader discussion on the ethical foundations of punishment, empathy, justice, and their implications on victims, urging a closer examination of the nuanced distinctions between acts of misconduct and grave crimes.
Verbal Abuse and Emotional scars:
Verbal abuse and emotional neglect can leave deep wounds that may be invisible but no less damaging. The role-playing scene towards the climax of the movie “Animal” portrays the dynamics between Ranvijay Singh (played by Ranbir Kapoor) and his father, Balbir Singh (played by Anil Kapoor) with emotion and introspection.
During the role-reversal game, the exchange between the son and father summarizes a profound moment of vulnerability, yearning, and unspoken pain. This scene recreates a past event that symbolizes the emotional void left by his father’s neglect, emphasizing the missed opportunities for connection and understanding. Ranvijay’s plea for his father to step into his shoes, even momentarily, and acknowledge his feelings and aspirations epitomizes the universal need for validation, empathy and recognition within the parent-child dynamic.
During the scene, which I have watched many times now, Ranvijay’s outburst, “I can hear, I am not deaf!” captures the frustration and sorrow of a son yearning for parental acknowledgement and emotional reciprocity, only to be met with silence and indifference. The power of that moment was in the portrayal of unspoken pain, unmet expectations, and the longing for connection that defines our deepest human relationships.
Sexual Abuse and Trauma
The alarming statistic that over 50% of abusers are individuals known to the child or in a position of trust and responsibility underscores the insidious nature of abuse and the betrayal of trust that often accompanies such violations. When perpetrators of abuse are individuals who hold positions of authority, care, or familiarity with the child, the impact of abuse can be devastating and complex. It’s even more devastation when the family of the survivor is in denial and refuses to acknowledge or address the abuse.
The experience of survivors of sexual abuse who are afraid to share their trauma with their families adds another layer of complexity to their emotional state and psychological wellbeing.
In her blog, Mrs. Kavita Chatterjee Das, Former Principal St. John’s Public School. Chandigarh, fearlessly delves into the harrowing reality of girl child sexual abuse. Through stark realism and raw emotion, the blog bravely sheds light on a topic often silenced by society.
(https://riseoneagleswings.blogspot.com/2014/10/telling-truth.html)
Reflections from Media
Drawing inspiration from certain scenes of fictional narratives like The West Wing, Animal, Monsoon Wedding, Highway, true stories such as An American Crime and many more, we’re are reminded of thought-provoking scenarios that challenge our perception of justice, empathy, human behaviour and suffering. These stories serve as mirrors to our own experiences, prompting us to question societal norms and personal values.
Conclusion
Addressing the concept of forgiveness for perpetrators of abuse on children, here is a suggested question for the reader based on what Pope Francis (played by Jonathan Pryce) says in the movie the “The Two Popes”:
“Confession cleans the sinner’s soul, it doesn’t help the victim… Sin is a wound, not a stain… It needs to be treated, healed. Forgiveness is not enough,”
How do you interpret this idea in the context of addressing the complexities of healing and justice for victims of abuse? Abuse during childhood whether it is physical, verbal or sexual can have profound physical and mental consequences that extend well into adulthood. From personality disorders to PTSD, guilt, clinical depression, substance abuse, and the fear of further harm and more, the effects of abuse can be far-reaching, leading to a cycle of acute trauma and pain.
I will leave you, the reader, to reflect on your own beliefs, values and perspectives regarding forgiveness and accountability.